How to Decide on a Car: Your Complete Guide
Make informed decisions and avoid costly mistakes
Key Factors to Consider
- • Compare asking price to market value
- • Factor in total cost of ownership (5+ years)
- • Consider depreciation rates
- • Negotiate from a position of knowledge
- • Check recall history and common problems
- • Research average repair costs
- • Consider maintenance schedule and costs
- • Review owner complaints and TSBs
- • Higher mileage = more wear and potential issues
- • Check service history and maintenance records
- • Look for signs of accidents or damage
- • Get a pre-purchase inspection
- • Daily commute distance and driving style
- • Family size and cargo needs
- • Fuel economy requirements
- • Expected ownership duration
Red Flags to Watch For
If a vehicle has numerous recalls, especially for critical components like brakes, airbags, or engine issues, it may indicate systemic problems. Check if all recalls have been addressed.
A high number of owner complaints, especially for the same recurring issues, suggests the vehicle may have design flaws or quality problems that could affect you too.
If a car has significantly more miles than average for its age (e.g., 150,000 miles on a 3-year-old car), it may have been used for heavy-duty purposes like ride-sharing or long-distance commuting, leading to accelerated wear.
If a car is priced well below market value, there's usually a reason. It could have hidden damage, mechanical issues, a salvage title, or other problems that aren't immediately apparent.
Missing service records, irregular maintenance intervals, or evidence of deferred repairs can indicate the vehicle wasn't properly cared for, leading to future problems.
The Smart Buying Process
Research Before You Look
Use our decision tool to analyze the specific make, model, and year you're considering. Get data on reliability, common problems, and total cost of ownership before you even see the car in person.
Set Your Budget
Determine not just the purchase price, but your total budget including insurance, registration, taxes, and an emergency fund for unexpected repairs. Our tool helps you see the full 5-year cost picture.
Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection
Always have an independent mechanic inspect the vehicle before purchase. They can identify hidden problems, estimate repair costs, and give you leverage in negotiations.
Check the Vehicle History
Get a vehicle history report (Carfax, AutoCheck) to check for accidents, title issues, odometer discrepancies, and service records. This is essential for used car purchases.
Test Drive Thoroughly
Drive the car in various conditions - city streets, highways, and if possible, in the conditions you'll use it most. Listen for unusual noises, feel for vibrations, and test all features.
Negotiate from Data
Use the market value data and risk assessment from your decision report to negotiate confidently. Know the car's true value and any issues that justify a lower price.
Ready to Make a Smart Decision?
Get a comprehensive analysis of any car you're considering. Our data-driven reports give you the confidence to make the right choice.
Analyze a Car Now